Archives For Fukushima

Two_reactors

A tale of another two reactors

There’s been much debate over the years as whether various tolerance of risk approaches actually satisfy the legal principle of reasonable practicability. But there hasn’t to my mind been much consideration of the value of simply adopting the legalistic approach in situations when we have a high degree of uncertainty regarding the likelihood of adverse events. In such circumstances basing our decisions upon what can turn out to be very unreliable estimates of risk can have extremely unfortunate consequences. Continue Reading…

Preamble

The following is a critique of a teleconference conducted on the 16 March  between the UK embassy in Japan and the UK Governments senior scientific advisor and members of SAGE, a UK government crisis panel formed in the aftermath of the Japanese tsunami to advise on the Fukushima crisis. These comments pertain specifically to the 16 March (UK time) teleconference with the British embassy and the minutes of SAGE meetings on the 15th and 16th that preceded that teleconference. Continue Reading…

Resilience and common cause considered in the wake of hurricane Sandy

One of the fairly obvious lessons from Hurricane Sandy is the vulnerability of underground infrastructure such as subways, road tunnels and below grade service equipment to flooding events.

The New York City subway system is 108 years old, but it has never faced a disaster as devastating as what we experienced last night”

NYC transport director Joseph Lhota

Yet despite the obviousness of the risk we still insist on placing such services and infrastructure below grade level. Considering actual rises in mean sea level, e.g a 1 foot increase at Battery Park NYC since 1900, and those projected to occur this century perhaps now is the time to recompute the likelihood and risk of storm surges overtopping defensive barriers.

Continue Reading…

In an article published in the online magazine Spectrum Eliza Strickland has charted the first 24 hours at Fukushima. A sobering description of the difficulty of the task facing the operators in the wake of the tsunami.

Her article identified a number of specific lessons about nuclear plant design, so in this post I thought I’d look at whether more general lessons for high consequence system design could be inferred in turn from her list.

Continue Reading…

I’ve recently been reading John Downer on what he terms the Myth of Mechanical Objectivity. To summarise John’s argument he points out that once the risk of an extreme event has been ‘formally’ assessed as being so low as to be acceptable it becomes very hard for society and it’s institutions to justify preparing for it (Downer 2011).

Continue Reading…

Earthquake and Tsunami damage to Daiichi Fukushima 1 (Image Source: Digital Globe)

Bernard Sieker of Bielefield University has put together graphs of the just released TEPCO plant instrumentation data on the Fukushima Daiichi plant (1).

The operators TEPCO had apparently heavily instrumented the plant prior to the tsunami.

My thanks to his colleague Peter Ladkin in publishing this link on the York Safety Critical Mailing List. Aa Peter points out the data is instructive.

So class homework, put together an event timeline against the instrument data, extra points for pictures. 🙂 Continue Reading…