Archives For ISO 61508

Work-Health-and-Safety

I’ll give you a hint it’s not pretty

Current Australian rail and workplace safety legislation requires that safety risks be either eliminated, or if that’s not possible be reduced, ‘so far as is reasonably practicable’. The intent is to ensure that all reasonable practicable precautions are in place, not to achieve some target level of risk.

There are two elements to what is ‘reasonably practicable’. A duty-holder must first consider what can be done – that is, what is possible in the circumstances for ensuring health and safety. They must then consider whether it is reasonable, in the circumstances to do all that is possible. This means that what can be done should be done unless it is reasonable in the circumstances for the duty-holder to do something less.

Worksafe  Australia

This is a real and intractable problem for standards that determine the degree of effort applied to treat a hazard using an initial assessment of risk (1). Nor can the legislation be put aside through appeals to such formalisms as the ALARP principle, or the invocation of a standard such as AS 61508 (2). In essence if you can do something, regardless of the degree of risk, then something should be done.  Continue Reading…

…and the value of virtuous witnesses

I have to say that I’ve never been terribly impressed with ISO 61508, given it purports to be so arcane that it require a priesthood of independent safety assessors to reliably interpret and sanction its implementation. My view is if your standard is that difficult then you need to rewrite the standard.

Which is where I would have parked my unhappiness with the general 61508 concept of an ISA, until I remembered a paper written by John Downer on how the FAA regulates the aerospace sector. Within the FAA’s regulatory framework there exists an analog to the ISA role, in the form of what are called Designated Engineering Representatives or DERs. In a similar independent sign-off role to the ISAs, DERs are paid by the company they work for to carry out a certifying function on behalf of the FAA.

Continue Reading…