Archives For Peter Ladkin

IEC 61508 dissected

28/04/2014

I’ve just reread Peter Ladkin’s 2008 dissection of the conceptual problems of IEC 61508 here, and having just worked through a recent project in which 61508 SILs were applied, I tend to agree that SIL is still a bad idea, done badly… I’d also add that, the HSE’s opinion notwithstanding, I don’t actually see that the a priori application of a risk derived SIL level to a specific software development acquits ones ‘so far as is reasonably practicable’ duty of care. Of course if your regulator says it does, why then smile bravely and complement him on the wonderful cut of his new clothes. On the other hand if you’re design the safety system for a nuclear plant maybe have a look at how the aviation industry do business with their Design Assurance Levels. 🙂